fitnessratchet.com

Here are 20 common diet and exercise myths, with explanations attached:

1) If you eat a low-fat diet you’ll lose weight

Fat as a macronutrient has little effect one way or the other on your weight loss efforts. Fat is high in calories, and it’s fairly dense so it’s easy to overeat, but if you’re controlling your total calorie intake the number of fat grams you consume won’t have much impact on your overall weight loss.

2) Situps will give you washboard abs

Spot reduction, that is removing fat in one particular area, is not possible without surgery. Situps will tend to build some muscle tissue in the abdominal region, but the only way to have a flat stomach is a proper diet that reduces your overall bodyfat percentage.

3) Women need to train differently than men

Women’s muscle tissue is virtually identical to men’s, the methods and effects will be very similar. Women do have a different hormonal balance, which does mean it will be somewhat more difficult to pack on lots of lean tissue, especially in the upper body, but proper weight training programs for men and women will be indistinguishable from each other.

4) Use light weights and high reps to “Tone” your muscles

Muscle tone is combination of muscular hypertrophy and low bodyfat percentage. Light weights and high repetitions will tend to create cardio or endurance type adaptations such as increased tolerance to lactic acid buildup, but this has little positive effect on appearance.

5) If I’m not sore, I didn’t have a good workout

Soreness is not a good indicator of workout quality. If you increased your power output since your last workout, then you did well, if you didn’t then you did not, no matter how sore you are.

6) If I lift weights, I’ll swell up and look like a bodybuilder in no time, yuck!

Professional bodybuilders spend years lifting weights, eating strict diets and taking boatloads of pharmaceuticals, most people couldn’t look like that if they tried, let alone by accident. If by some odd circumstance you manage to gain more muscle than you want, it’s pretty easy to slow your progress or even lose some by reversing the normal recommendations.

7) Eating red meat is bad for you

This is a leftover from the 80’s. While you don’t want to go crazy on saturated fats, lean beef is a healthy part of a balanced diet. This isn’t license to pig out on chorizo at all hours, but having a steak isn’t going to make you seize up and keel over at the dinner table.

8) Fruit juice is better for you than soda

Sadly, the main component of both items is sugar, and that’s not a good thing. Fruit juice tends to be high in calories, and cause a severe insulin impact, you’ll want to avoid it for the most part.

9) Skipping meals promotes fat loss

Not eating for prolonged periods tends to put you in a catabolic (muscle wasting) state, which is counter-productive from a fat loss perspective as it will lower your metabolism.

10) Protein is bad for your kidneys

Unless you have a pre-existing kidney condition, protein is perfectly safe and necessary. Excessive amounts, over 2g/lb of bodyweight are generally not recommended, but that’s A LOT, you’ll be hard pressed to eat the recommended amount of 1.25g/lb of lean body mass so I wouldn’t worry about it.

11) Squats are bad for your knees

Done with proper form, squats are actually beneficial to knee health. As with all exercises, not using proper form is not good for you.

12) You should always lift to failure

Failure can be useful in some training modalities, but it’s certainly not a requirement. Overall it tends to impose more stress on the nervous system than normal modes of training and should be used sparingly.

13) Running is the best way to get fit, in fact you don’t need anything else

Cardiovascular exercise is a key component to any fitness plan, but without hypertrophy training, it can actually have negative affects on appearance, marathon runners for example.

14) Supplements are magic, taking them will make you thin and fit without effort

No one has yet invented the magic weight loss pill, and if they did you’d need a prescription to get it. Anything you can buy over the counter is either a waste of money, or will provide less than 5% increase in performance. That 5% can be handy when you’ve already maxed out all your other factors, but don’t think you’re going to pop a few pills and be transformed overnight.

15) The smith machine is a safer way to do many exercises

This piece of machinery is so dangerous it should probably be banned from most gyms. Due to it’s restricted range of motion, it tends to be very hard on your joints. The machine is quite difficult to use safely, and honestly unless you’re a professional with some sort of specialized requirement you should just stay away from it.

16) No pain, no gain

Pain is the body’s natural warning mechanism, ignore it at your peril. That said it’s important to learn the difference between pain and discomfort. Pain is bad, and generally leads to injury. Discomfort is a normal part of training, and should be expected.

17) Vegetarianism is a more natural, healthier way to eat

Homo Sapiens Sapiens (that’s you) is an opportunistic omnivore, which means that both animals and plants are a normal part of your diet. Look in the mirror and smile with your teeth showing, start in the center and count outwards, see that third tooth? It’s called a canine tooth, and it’s specifically designed for tearing flesh. Animals which ignore parts of their natural food supply do not live healthy lives. (Note: If you have moral reasons for being a vegetarian, I can understand and even applaud that, but don’t go around claiming it’s good for you.)

18) Vegetarians can’t build muscle

Not true. Plants contain incomplete proteins, so it’s possible, though very difficult, to create a balanced diet using only plant food sources by using carefully planned food combinations. You’ll need to take a variety of vitamins and supplements to make up for micronutrient deficiencies, the protein density is low so you’ll need to eat like a horse (hah, no pun intended), and an improperly designed vegetarian diet can impair brain function, but it is possible.

19) You’ll burn more fat at a lower exercise intensity

This is true, but in a misleading way. While a greater percentage of calories burned at lower intensity will come from fat storage, you’ll burn more overall calories from fat at higher intensity, rendering the percentage meaningless. Always be suspicious of someone saying the easier path is the right path.

20) More exercise is always better

If only that were true. In the US, it’s a pretty common belief that if you want something, working harder at it is the best way to get it. For some things this is true, for exercise doing more than your body can recover from will actually reduce your results. This is not an excuse to be lazy but a warning not to overdo it. That said, most people tend to under-train, not over-train.

Muscle growth is a two part process. First, the muscle is damaged during heavy use, this effect is called micro-trauma. Second, the body repairs the tissue, and like any good repairman throws on a little extra “for luck” in the hopes that it won’t have to do this again. In order to create further growth you must increase the stimulus, which can be measured by the power output.

Power = Work / Time

Work = Force * Distance

Force = Mass * Acceleration

So putting it all together:

Power = (Mass * Acceleration * Distance) / Time

So why did we get all fancy about that? In order to talk about progression in lifting weights it’s necessary to understand what progression means. If today you lift 4×8x215 (four sets of eight reps of two hundred fifteen pounds) and tomorrow you do 5×5x220 did you progress? If you’re thinking simplistically, then the obvious answer seems to be yes, after all there was more weight on the bar right? If the distance stays the same, which it often does for the same lift, and you don’t vary the acceleration or time (which is far less guaranteed, in fact heavier lifts often end up slower with longer breaks) then on a mass basis alone, you’re still putting out 21% less power with the second scheme.

With hypertrophy training, the total power exerted by the muscles is what determines the amount of damage they take, and thus how much repair work (growth) they’re going to do. Generally the easiest way to progress is to add weight to the bar, but your other choices include lifting faster, taking shorter rest breaks, increasing the overall distance of the lift (such as doing full squats rather than just to parallel), and changing the set/rep parameters to produce higher overall loading. For me, I like to change as few variables as possible, so I focus on the weight almost exclusively. For many lifters this is difficult, as they can’t progress by 5lbs every session, but this is actually fairly easily solved by using fractional plates. The standard smallest plates are 2.5lbs each (adding up to 5lbs if you have one on each side), but if you go to Piedmont Design Associates they have a selection of sub 2.5lb plates like these:

This particular set contains everything from 1/16th through 1lb plates, and I’ve found it enormously helpful. If you don’t have access to quality hardware like this though you can achieve similar results by adding reps and sets. So the first week you might do 4×8x215, then 5×8x215, then 6×8x215, at which point you’re probably ready for 220. Another way of doing that would be to start with 4×8x215, then 4×9x215, then 4×10x215, then you’re probably ready for 220. As you can see, that’s all quite a bit more complex than just going 4×8x215, 4×8x217, 4×8x218.5, then being ready for 220.

So now that we know a little bit about muscle growth and progression, I’m going to give you a cardinal rule:

You only grow when you’re recovering, never while you’re in the gym.

This is a pretty important concept, basically what it’s saying is that you need to remember that gym time is damage, it’s only when your body is repairing itself that you’re going to make progress. Too much gym time, too much damage, can actually exceed your bodies ability to effect repairs and cause you to experience less progress for more work.

So how much exercise is optimum? The exact answer depends on a large number of variables including things like your nutritional strategy, genetic makeup, lifestyle choices, training age, recovery methods and many other factors. In general, your exercise density as expressed by number of separate exercises per week is going to be best between 15-25 total exercises. More is better until you overdo it, so you’ll want to be conservative, start at the lower end, and slowly work your way up.

Here’s a second rule for you:

The more often you train a muscle, the faster it will grow, assuming adequate recovery.

While recovery time varies a bit between different muscle groups, they tend to be ready for more training somewhere between 24-48 hours after the first session. Waiting longer than a week between training sessions generally doesn’t produce much in the way of results. So essentially we want to train them as often as possible without exhausting ourselves, with the time between varying between 2-7 days.

Your exact plan is going to depend on where you can free up time during your daily and weekly schedules. One consideration, is that a workout session of longer than 90 minutes (actual time lifting weights, driving, warmup, showers, etc. don’t count) tends to be counterproductive as your cortisol levels will start to spike. Cortisol is a catabolic (muscle wasting) stress hormone, and we want to avoid creating large amounts of it, since that would tend to cancel out all our hard work. Doing too many exercises in one session is also a problem, as your energy levels will be so depleted by the time you reach the end that you won’t be putting out anywhere near full effort. Generally I wouldn’t do more than six exercises per session, and even that is quite a few, I prefer a schedule with less.

One common strategy is the Monday-Wednesday-Friday workout, six exercises per session. This results in a weekly density of eighteen exercises, well within tolerance, and an average workout length of about an hour and fifteen minutes, which while long is doable. Given the twelve exercises we talked about last week, you’d divide them into to two halves, and workout on an A/B schedule:

A Day - Squats, Pullups, Military Press, Dips, Decline Weighted Situps, Supported Forearm Roller

B Day - Stiff Legged Deadlifts, Calf Raises, Bench Press, Cable Row, Trap Bar Shrugs, Barbell Curls

There are three main problems with that schedule. First, since it’s tied to specific weekdays, how do you compensate when you miss a day? Second, those workouts are going to be pretty draining energy wise. Third, with so many off days, it may be difficult to maintain motivation, personally I do much better when something is shorter, easier, and more frequent. I prefer to use “cycles” rather than days. Basically you string together a series of workout days and recovery days, and just keep repeating that. The advantage is that you’re not tied to a seven day period, and if you miss a day, you just pick right back where you left off in the cycle. Here’s what I’m currently using to good effect:

Day 1 - Pullups, Military Press, Dips, Decline Weighted Situps

Day 2 - Bench Press, Cable Row, Trap Bar Shrugs, Barbell Curls

Day 3 - Squat, Calf Raises, Stiff Legged Deadlifts, Supported Forearm Roller

Day 4 - Off Day

Then I repeat days 1-3, take two off days, and start over. This produces an exercise density of 18.67 exercises per week, with an average workout time of 45 minutes. Even though it’s a nine day schedule, this has proved to be very easy to stick with. By monitoring your progress and fatigue levels you can decide when to raise your density, or when you could use some extra off days.

Some common signs of overdoing it are small injuries, excessive tiredness outside of your workouts, and muscle soreness persisting longer than normal. If you start experiencing any of that, it’s best to back off a little bit, your progress will be a lot better in the long run than if you push yourself too hard. As an example, I had been doing a four on one off schedule which worked great, but wasn’t maxing out my potential. I switched to three on one off, and that proved to be a bit too much. Now I’m doing 3 on 1 off, 3 on 2 off, and it’s working well. Progress is up, fatigue is under control.

Feel free to mix and match your own schedule, one that fits your lifestyle. As long as the overall density and workout length are kept within bounds, there are many configurations that can work successfully.